Showing posts with label KTM. Show all posts
Showing posts with label KTM. Show all posts

Saturday, October 18, 2025

Angkasapuri

Angkasapuri KTM - cut off by roads, rivers and restricted land

There are some seriously unloved KTM stations in Malaysia, but Angkasapuri must be near the top of the list - terrible car-brained planning that prioritises a highway and cuts off access to the station from nearly all directions, with a river to the east with no car-free crossing.

To top it off, the one place it does lead to (the Ministry of Communications and RTM complex) is not for public access and does not allow connections through it, so for any destinations on the other side, people will need to take a long detour around.  Some may say that the station was specifically opened for the complex - if that is the case it's just another terrible planning decision.  Public transport stations need to have maximum connectivity to the surrounding area, and not be exclusive to a condo or government department.

Looking at the areas around the station, there is housing at the top of Old Klang Road with temples and some shop lots (restaurants/ commercial).  Just to the south of this are several big tower blocks (Tria, Gemilang Indah and Vivo).  Staying within a 750m radius of the station (10 mins walk) we also see some large residential towers and commercial buildings on the opposite side of Old Klang Road (e.g. Avara).  On the west side there is Taman Bukit Angkasa - again, lots of housing.

 
Angkasapuri KTM station (blue marker).  From left to right, running north-south: New Pantai Expressway, KTM port Klang line, Klang River, and Old Klang Road.  

So there is no shortage of housing and urban activity in close proximity to the station (and there is surely more on the way).  As is so often the case in Malaysia, the way the area has been planned and covered with roads makes it difficult and inconvenient to get to public transport without a car, increasing the need to use cars.  The vicious cycle continues.  This results in Angkasapuri station having the lowest ridership on the whole KTM Komuter network.

First photo: PPR Kampung Limau (foreground), River Park (background). Second photo: Tria condos.

Adjacent to the station there are two condos under construction - the huge River Park Bangsar South, and the smaller RIA Apartment.  These will have direct access to the KTM station when completed.  Predictably, during construction, the access to the station is partially blocked or not maintained, further discouraging public transport use.  Together with these developments,  new transport infrastructure is being built.  Can you guess what type? (More on that later.) 

Example of the condition of access routes to Angkasapuri KTM Station in October 2025

Rail connections

This KTM stop is on the route to Port Klang and Batu Caves.  For people going in either of those two directions the train obviously has the capability of being a very convenient mode of transport.  Seputeh Station is just 900m to the east, but on the Tanjung Malim/ Seremban line.  If people living near Seputeh Station wanted to head towards PJ, Klang or Batu Caves using the train they would need to ride it north to KL Sentral, change onto the Port Klang Line (or another metro line) and head out again.  This would add a lot of time given how slow and infrequent the train is - people are unlikely to find it feasible.  Much simpler and quicker if they could easily walk or cycle to Angkasapuri station and hop on their direct train (and vice versa to Seputeh Station).

  

The two lines on the Klang Valley KTM Komuter network. Perhaps one day Malaysian planning will allow trains to be routed to multiple destinations rather than the limited routes currently available.  

The potential capacity of these KTM Komuter lines is considerable, seen as part of KL's high frequency high volume urban metro system.  For this it needs the infrastructure, the trains, the stations, the information systems, and the maintenance. It needs people to work together to achieve this goal, which is still a long way off realisation.  

The fact is, urban rail is a much more efficient mode of transport than urban car. When a city gets as big as Kuala Lumpur/ Klang Valley efficiency becomes increasingly vital.  

 
 Trains vs cars - which moves more people?

The picture above could easily be Old Klang Road (OKR), although it's not from Malaysia.  OKR also has a railway roughly parallel to it, with three stations all within 600m of the road (Angkasapuri, Pantai Dalam, and Petaling).  Basically nobody is using them to get to OKR because the connections are just too poor.

Old Klang Road is famously congested with traffic and unpleasant for pedestrians and bicycle users.  It has become a 'stroad' as the authorities have sought to add as many lanes as physically possible, in the misguided notion that it will reduce traffic.  Obviously giving more space to cars and relegating people to broken pavements and steep overhead bridges just encourages more cars and more traffic.  A half-hearted attempt to implement bus lanes may have helped a little but it hasn't done much to encourage active travel - something Malaysians so desperately need (lower stress, healthier, more efficient etc etc).

Recent developments

There may be some green shoots appearing - for example the Klang River Festival project to create a riverside path along the banks of the Klang River adjacent to OKR.  This could provide a major boost to walking and cycling, as well as amenity value, if connected well with the destinations along the river corridor, and with access to public transport.  Some details of the proposals are available here, as well as a screenshot of the map below.  These proposals go a little way to addressing the area's wider need for walkability. Thinking about the bigger connectivity question, a strategic pedestrian crossing could make a big difference in the area.  The map below has been marked up with a possible crossing location to unlock the potential of Angkasapuri station. 

Map showing some proposed pathways along the Klang River.  Lime green markup showing possible location of pedestrian crossing.  (North direction towards the right.)

Solutions

Remember, to go 800m you do not need a car, a van or a bus.  Don't tell people to get in a van and problem solved.  This just encourages even more car-brained thinking and turns a blind eye to the accessibility issues that could be solved with better planning and design.

As usual it is a case of getting the basics right, which are so often overlooked by poor Malaysian planning and design. 

  • Access routes and covered walkways             
  • Bridges across railways and rivers
  • Accessible stations (lifts, escalators, ramps)
  • At-grade crossings of roads 
  • Lighting and signage
  • Co-ordinated public transport (e.g. buses and trains)
  • Bicycle, scooter and motorbike parking 

The station currently doesn't even have ramps or lifts - accessibility is very poor.  To enter from the east side requires hiking over one pedestrian bridge, going through the barriers, then crossing over another pedestrian bridge to get back to the east side platform (ridiculous). 

 
Angkasapuri station sandwiched up against the New Pantai Expressway

To maximise the potential of our public transport systems they must be made convenient.  This means accessing them WITHOUT A CAR. That means having car-free access routes (something that seems to be anathema to Malaysian planners).  The map below shows more closely how this could be achieved.  Additionally, permissive pathways through Angkasapuri could be a quick and effective solution to boost connectivity to the west of the station. 

 

Zoomed in proposal for pedestrian crossing of the Klang River connecting into Angkasapuri station and beyond (new bridge in red colour).  (North direction upwards.)

Funding 

People may ask where would the money come from for these kinds of improvements.  The first thing to remember is that pedestrian bridges, paths and covered walkways are relatively cheap.  So it's not a lot of money.  

The KTM line itself is already there (and has been since before Malaysia was a country) and the Klang Valley Double Tracking project is underway (albeit painfully slowly - but that's another story).  As that project progresses, new funding should be made available to enhance the accessibility of KTM stations - lifts, fare gates on both sides of the station, information systems, signage, and general maintenance.  Also not that expensive compared to car infra.

Just look around and you will see so much car infrastructure in Malaysia - very very heavy and expensive.  Old Klang Road has been widened, barriers installed, car ramps tying in at various locations.  Again, this is expensive infra, costly to build and maintain.  So it's a question of priorities.  Car infra has been massively prioritised, with very high costs, over cheaper car-free infra.

This prioritisation is happening right now in 2025 at this location.  The new condo projects next to the KTM station will have car ramps binding them to surrounding highways.  In articles about the project, the developer boasts of 'investing' in connectivity: 

"A RM25 million infrastructure investment is currently underway to construct an exclusive road link to the Federal Highway and the New Pantai Expressway (NPE), scheduled to be completed in tandem with River Park" 

How much has been 'invested' in the pedestrian walkway?  And how much would a pedestrian bridge over the Klang River cost?  Less than RM25m, for sure.  These kinds of huge condo projects have significant impacts on the areas around them and there is very little being done by developers or local authorities (e.g. DBKL) to make sure sensible supporting infrastructure is implemented alongside them.

Condo plans show the new 'link bridge' that is being built (see columns under construction).  It's for cars.
 
Foundations being constructed alongside the Klang River apposite Vivo.  Could this be for a pedestrian bridge?  No.  It's 2025, it's Malaysia, and that means more car ramps for condos with dizzying amounts of parking.  

The pathways along the Klang River (aka extension of River of Life) may have their own funding source following the work that Klang River Festival and KongsiKL have been doing (can that channel some DBKL funding too?).  The new pedestrian bridge to the KTM station could be funded by a Railway Asset Core accessibility improvement fund, and/ or by the adjacent condos that are under development, along with DBKL.


 
It's 2025 and the best option local residents have of crossing the river is to walk on the highway bridge.

A livable future?

The good thing is it's not too late - installing a pedestrian bridge over the Klang is absolutely possible as is implementing a network of pedestrian/ cycling paths with some canopies.  In time, some of the road space can be easily converted into other uses - small linear parks, trees for shade, pathways, perhaps some space for warungs, cycle lanes, and at-grade pedestrian crossings.  The river corridor can be an active travel artery doubling up as a recreational space and refuge against the concrete jungle. 

In time, dedicated bus lanes should be extended along many major roads.  Even better, for Old Klang Road, build an at-grade tram line.  Reconfigure this choked stroad into something suitable for a productive, efficient artery in a livable city.  Give Old Klang Road a new lease of life and unlock the potential of KL's railways and rivers.

 
A glimpse at Old Klang Road's future?
 

Saturday, January 14, 2023

Skypark Link

What's not to like?

A convenient, high capacity and affordable rail link from KL's cute city airport to its central transportation hub. 

The Skypark Link, opened in May 2018, will take you from Subang Airport straight into KL Sentral.

Sounds like a really good idea.  And the execution?

Here goes.

The basics are there - a twin-track, electrified railway line with a station close to the airport.  Let's start with the station access. After going to the expense of building a train station 200m away from the airport building, the planners (or those above them) then went and threw the benefits away in typical fashion - by making it awkward to access. 

The major problems come from the usual suspects - cars and car infrastructure.  

There is a pedestrian bridge connected into the airport building, although this is not well sign-posted.  There is also no train departure screen in the airport, so you don't get convenient information for the next trains.  This information can be so useful - it can be the difference between relaxing while sipping a cold brew, or hurrying over to the train station only to find that the train just left and there isn't one for another hour.

The bridge is covered, but has a steep spiral staircase and small lift that spits you out next to the car park.  While it may be called a pedestrian bridge, it is really infrastructure for cars.  To keep people 'out of the way'.  

From the lift to the station is just across the car park.  But, surprise surprise, cars have been prioritised again, so pedestrians have to make their way along the path skirting the edge of the car park.  This is about a 280m walk, with a cover.  If you try to walk directly towards the station, a guard will wildly blow his whistle at you (but probably won't be bothered to chase you).  

Once you get near to the station, if you walked inside the car park, you'll be greeted by a fence and a gate.   Locked of course.


After going up to bridge level, down to the car park, and walking a total of 345m (if you follow the designated route) you finally make it to the train station - and don't exactly get a welcoming greeting.


A dull, boring ticket area with information displays not function properly.  If you are ready to catch your train, you then have to go up to platform level.  So to recap, it's up to the bridge, down to car park, and up again to platform.  

Now to the train.  There is roughly one every hour, although it's slightly randomised and doesn't leave at the same time past each hour (ktmb.com.my/TrainTime.html). It takes about 35 minutes to get to KL Sentral (after stopping only at Subang Jaya on the way). 35 minutes may not sound bad, but let's think about that.  The route is about 26km.  So average speed is 26 / (35/60) = 45 kph.  This is very poor.  For comparison, the KLIA Ekspres takes about 28 minutes to go 57 km (118 kph average speed).  Granted, Skypark has to share tracks with all the other KTM services for most of the route, and there are railway upgrading works going on nearer to KL.  But really, this is painfully slow.

With low traffic, you can make it from Subang Airport to KL Sentral in a car in 25 minutes.  

The train itself is a commuter style affair, with lots of luggage storage space. 


The driver's door wouldn't close, so you might get to see the journey through the windscreen (better than through the dirty windows.)  But the train does the job.

A ticket was originally RM 11 between the airport and KL Sentral.  In 2022 this was drastically cut - to RM 3.50 - presumably in a (desperate?) bid to improve the ridership of the service.    


After spending your RM 3.50 and arriving into KL Sentral - you might be greeted by ...

Broken escalators!

To summarise the Skypark experience. 
- Awkward to get from airport to station
- Cheap
- Slow
- Reasonably good destinations for onward connections (Subang Jaya and KL Sentral).

The good news for the Skypark link is that its technical problems can be addressed very simply.  

1. Build an elevated walkway across the car park directly into the station.  Connect directly into platform level so that those who don't need to buy a ticket can go straight through some barriers onto the platform.  Add functioning train departure screens in the airport and include clearer signage to funnel people towards the train. 

2. If an elevated walkway isn't going to happen (for whatever reason), re-route the walking path at ground level in a straight line through the car park.  Also, add escalators between the bridge and the car park.  These escalators should be in line with the intended direction of travel.  Reconfigure the parking bays around the walking route to make this work.  Prioritise the pedestrians - it's that simple.  There's plenty of guidance around on how to make good, accessible routes.


3. Address the frequency and speed of the train service (this is a whole other topic, and, granted, will take a long time before it's possible). 

(As a bonus point, sort the bridge out over the NKVE.  The one that lorries keep crashing into because it's too low.)

Friday, September 23, 2022

Penang Sentral

Overall impressions

Oh dear, poor, poor Penang Sentral.  Where to start.

The design of this 'interchange' is shocking.   Leaving aside the hideous architecture, how does it function as an interchange?

Penang Sentral

The function of an interchange is to seamlessly and smoothly bring together different modes of transport at one nexus.  This should encompass as many modes as relevant and practical.

Butterworth is an obvious place, having a ferry port and a railway station already converging at the same point.  Bring together a bus terminal, a bicycle hub, and a vehicular drop off point, and the idea makes perfect sense. 

Unfortunately, the planners seemed to lose sight of this and decided to build a giant multistorey car park instead, adding on some awkward bus stops and a load of bizarre ramps.   (My advice to anyone planning urban transport in Malaysia: keep it on the ground.  Design out the need for ramps.  If you need lots of ramps, you are doing it wrong.)

Take the bicycle connection between the railway station and the ferry, for example.

In 2021, all but one of the big classic ferries were retired, now replaced by a small boat for foot passengers.  Bicycles and motorcycles are left with a modest 1 per hour.  OK, fine.  We can wait for the ferry.  Very cheap too. 

However, getting onto the ferry or to the railway station is a different story.   Up the ramp, round and round, down, through the toll booth, wait in the queue. 

Out of the port, through the barriers, up the spiral ramp, down another ramp, contra-flow along the main road (no decent pavement), into the station car park area, and then finally reaching the station. 

Time and time again Malaysia takes the long wiggly route to somewhere that is so near in a straight line.

The figure below shows a route you could take between the KTM station and ferry terminal, if you use contraflow. It's about 1.2km. Seriously. (If you don't use contraflow (i.e. cycling into traffic), it's way longer.)

Route between ferry terminal and KTM station for those using bicycle, scooter etc.  This could be solved easily by opening up a route near the toll booths directly into the railway station. 

Connections to the town 

A key issue with transit stations in Malaysia is their connections to the surrounding area - how accessible they are to local communities.  Penang Sentral is no different - in fact it is particularly poor.  The image below shows that there are significant residential and industrial areas within a 2km radius (25 minutes' walk or less, 10 minutes cycling/ scooting, or less).  If given convenient pathways to get to Penang Sentral, no doubt many would consider using the hub to catch their regional bus, ferry to Georgetown, local train, or perhaps long distance train.

Population areas within 2km of Penang Sentral.  

  • The residential area to the south east, across the Prai river, is disconnected as there is no bridge.  (The Prai River Bridge is a major highway bridge - no entry for pedestrians.) 
  • Residential/ kampung area directly to the east: good luck finding a decent cycle route, footpath or safe crossing points to get into Penang Sentral from here.
  • Butterworth town to the north - you could try walking down Highway 1, which has a footbridge and some zig-zag pathways (not much shade).  It will probably take you a lot longer than it should.  Once you get to Penang Sentral, how do you actually get in?
A typical footpath on the way to the Butterworth railway station. 

It's a similar story trying to get directly into the railway station from the local areas.  Terrible paths, carparks in the way, entry roads jammed with traffic, major highway blocking access. 


During construction 

Like most construction projects in Malaysia, access during construction was relegated to the lowest priority. During the construction of Penang Sentral, it was not permitted to walk from the railway station to the ferry terminal (about 240m, or 3-4 minutes' walk). Pedestrians had to take a bus around the construction site, which inevitably took much longer. Perhaps not so bothersome to Malaysians, but it left plenty of foreign tourists disgruntled and confused.  Construction projects (especially ones near transport hubs) need to be planned to maintain adequate access throughout construction for active travel modes.  This is not difficult to do, and forms part of the standard practice for projects in other countries not so far away from Malaysia.  It does, however, need a change in mindset, together with enforcement from planning authorities and major clients. 

Kampung Attap

People may know Kampung Attap, in central KL, for its cafes, the Zhongshan building, or perhaps the Selangor Badminton association.  It'...