Showing posts with label Transport planning. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Transport planning. Show all posts

Saturday, November 22, 2025

NPE2

Another Highway in the City

This month another big, elevated highway has been announced, running into the heart of Kuala Lumpur.

The NPE2 would run from Pantai Dalam to Jalan Istana via Jalan Syed Putra. 

But the city is already covered in grey spaghetti concrete highways.  Government ministers, planners and engineers stuck in the 1980's want to cover Malaysia in even more of it.

It takes a severe case of carbrain to see this image and decide what it needs is more roads.


Every new iteration of highway gets uglier and nastier looking with poor design details and jarring blocky angles.  Bad drainage and poor maintenance lead to staining which completes the look.

 

 Funny how just one or two cars are shown on these images, but in reality the roads will induce demand and fill up to the brim within a few years (which is what the business case demands).

What can be done to curb Malaysian developers' insatiable appetite for more elevated urban highways?  How many levels will be enough?  Is it because they can't build flying cars, they feel the need to take normal cars high into the sky on concrete monstrosities?

It's way past time to take things in a better direction.  Adding highway after highway just makes things worse in the long run.

Another Way for the City

There is another way and it's simple: build alternative infra and shift to moving people, not cars.

Scale back the roads in central KL, bring in a congestion charge.  Watch people shift to walking, cycling, buses, and metro.

Build tram lines at-grade.  It works for other cities, why not KL? In this case, build an at-grade tram line along Jalan Syed Putra and Old Klang Road.  We need an alternative vision.  Imagine the convenience of a tram line with regular stops all the way along Old Klang Road, with interchanges at Midvalley, Tun Sambanthan, and up to Pasar Seni. 

Concept for a tram line along Jalan Syed Putra and Old Klang Road.  No need for elevated infrastructure.
 

Malaysian contractor Gamuda is buying trams for Taipei.  Malaysian developer YTL is helping build a new railway station in the UK.  Why can't it be done in Malaysia?

The government spent billions on the River of Life project and now the plan is to dominate it with an elevated highway, destroying the amenity value of the river and undoing that investment.  The highway will pump out noise, fumes and particulates into the city's air. 

Spending billions on all these highways and road projects just locks KL into a future of car dependency.  Obviously a good thing for the toll highway guys...

Fake targets and ulterior motives 

The Malaysian government has targets of 40% public transport share by 2030 and 70% by 2040 for KL.  These are actual targets from the government.  Yet the Works Ministry, part of the same government, is approving urban highways, directly undermining the government target.  So what is the point of the target if they are just going to ignore it?  The government seriously needs to get the priorities in order.

The people behind this crazy American-style highway development need to be un-brainwashed and retrained so they can design and build balanced transport infrastructure for our cities, one that doesn't constantly prioritise cars and profit.

 

 

Wednesday, July 19, 2023

MRT Serdang Raya Utara

This is a new station on the MTR Putrajaya Line, which finally opened in March 2023.

Billions of ringgit were spent on the new MRT line but station access is still a failure. It is not that difficult to understand desire lines and create convenient pedestrian crossings.




The station is opposite a bustling area - it should be as easy as possible to get to the station from here. But there is a 6 lane road in the way and fences along the walkway under the station.

Bridges, ramps, escalators, lifts have all been included in the design, but crossing the road has not been solved. Come on MRTCorp and MBSJ. It’s time to prioritise walking and wheelingπŸšΆπŸ½πŸ§‘πŸΎ‍πŸ¦½πŸ‘©πŸ»‍πŸ¦―πŸ›΄πŸš².


This is just one example of poor access into a big MRT station. There are many more/ worse examples.

So there is a long term problem with this stuff. MRTCorp and the councils need to do some serious thinking about the purpose of MRT stations.
It is critical that the stakeholders *work together* and the integration plan for the station and surrounding area needs to be prioritised - it’s not optional. Quite often it is nothing to do with cost - it is just prioritising the right things and using good design principles.
These design principles are fairly straightforward - give a good design consultant the guidance and they will come up with something that works. The hard part is getting that standard and guidance in place, agreeing to prioritise what needs to be prioritised, and daring to slow down car drivers for the benefit of more efficient modes of city transport.
Interestingly, someone posted an earlier design of the station access, which included a footbridge across the road.
https://twitter.com/JdUnknownperson/status/1675079230970015744?s=20
There have been comments on the Twitter post about cut-backs - perhaps this footbridge was one of the casualties. However, footbridges are rarely the answer, and access into stations can be excellent without footbridges. (The footbridges in Brickfields, which are very high but only take you across a narrow road, take the concept of footbridges across roads to extremes of absurdity.) Usually, a simple pedestrian crossing will be all that's needed, as long as it gives priority to pedestrians. This doesn't need to cost a lot of money and can usually be done within the same budget as the road resurfacing around the station.

Wednesday, January 19, 2022

Barriers in the city

Let’s talk about permeability.   No, this is not about hairstyles.  It’s about the ability to travel through a medium, place or object. Say, a city.


Places tend towards permeability if given the chance. Yes, there are rivers, steep hills, and forests to contend with, but by and large, people find a way through.  This is a human phenomenon.  An animal phenomenon.  


The generations before us knew about permeability.   Just a few generations ago,  riding around on a bicycle was a primary means of transport, and this relied on the permeability of the town or district.   In KL that has mostly been swept up and away in the mass of tangled highways.  You don’t have to look far to find people who growing up didn’t think of using a bicycle as ‘cycling’ - it was just jalan jalan, and it was free and easy.


The modern city in Malaysia is becoming a ‘severed’ place rather than a permeable one.  Forces are at work making this happen, going against the grain.   It is usually the construction of a wall or a fence.   Why do we need these barriers?   Why do we need to sever one place from another?  The two main causes of the barriers in the Klang Valley are highways and fenced property.    



Highways are touted as providing connectivity, but do the sponsors and planners stop to consider that highways also bring severance?  They sever districts through the insertion of fences and other barriers coupled with heavy traffic thundering along in a near-continuous stream.  Not something easy to cross, to say the least.  This can have far-reaching consequences for an area, resulting in severed communities.   What once was a short walk now may be a long drive, with little or no alternative but to get on the highway.  Cycle around the Klang Valley and you will usually find your preferred route blocked by highways.  Some footbridges are provided - but not nearly enough.  They clearly haven’t been planned with active travel in mind.  Of course, with highways typically being toll roads, it is in the developers’ and operators’ interests to encourage car use and discourage active travel. 


Cycling is an incredibly flexible mode of transport - you can ride 5 minutes to the shop, go touring (maybe with the help of a train), invade a country, or take it off road, over the hills and far away.  There are so many options.  So a bicycle can be used in a shared space with pedestrians, on a motorcycle lane, on a road, on a gravel track, or, yes, even on a dedicated bicycle path.  Perhaps this is a curse, as well as a blessing.  Without a well defined need for bicycle-specific infrastructure, cycling routes get overlooked. 


What this all means is that we’ve ended up with areas in Greater KL that you can’t escape except by using a highway.    Easy, accessible routes can be worked into highway proposals for little extra cost, if the will is there. 


Modern private property developments in the Klang Valley tend to be relatively large scale. A common first step for a developer is to put a big fence around the new development site, thus reducing permeability.   Attitudes towards private property, land access rights, so called ‘security’, and various other aspects of the collective psyche can probably explain this to some extent.  There are simpler explanations too.  Perhaps the planner or developer doesn’t walk or cycle.  That would be perfectly normal nowadays in the Klang Valley.   If they never use active travel themselves, why would they think to cater for others who might?  Everybody knows that cars are the only way...  Education in planning and urban design can tackle this, together with planning policy:   mitigate severance caused by developments, maintain and enhance urban permeability. 


On the other side of the coin, the Klang Valley has many mature housing areas that are inherently permeable, with little lanes, alleys, parks and bridges.  Nowadays, many of these areas are fenced, like a compound.   People approvingly talk about their area being ‘gated and guarded’ - hideous terms better suited to a barbed wire dystopia.   Nothing says selamat datang like a 10-foot fence topped with razor wire.    


Welcome to the neighbourhood.


But where does this trend for fences come from?  There has been a history of fenced housing areas in Malaya for decades, particularly acute during the emergency years.  The British set up New Villages with perimeter fences to combat communist activity.  Did the residents decide they liked the fences?  Or did they just get used to it and as time went by, forgot that it could be different?  It is sad that people use the warped excuse of ‘security’ or ‘safety’ today (but that is a discussion for another time).


Let’s look at a few quick examples of severance caused by fences.


There is a road from TTDI, through Kampung Penchala and up to Desa Park City.  Well, there was once. It was a pleasant and convenient route on the bicycle, using a small lane along a babbling river.   Even better, the end of the road was a modal filter, blocking motorised traffic.  This made the road quiet and calm.  In 2021 the route was blocked by an uncompromising fence and barbed wire.  Some try to bypass the fence by going through the forest - a route unsuitable for most.  It looks like a typical case of the ‘one way in, one way out’ mentality.   With a little imagination and minimal budget, the route could be opened up to active travel, with all the benefits that would bring.


The developer is ParkCity Holdings, a subsidiary of Samling.  From Samling’s own website: “Samling Group and all its subsidiaries strongly believe in environmental protection and sustainable social-economic practices which caters to long-term business growth”. 

Just going to leave that there.


The road to Desa Park, now blocked.


There will surely be arguments for and against barriers in each situation, and in some rare cases a fence might be the least worst option.  But the point isn’t about one example, the point is that this is a trend and it’s happening everywhere.  Maybe permeability for active travel around the city just isn’t on anyone’s radar.  The people whom it currently affects the most are probably foreign workers, with little if any voice in these kinds of matters.  Maybe there is nobody representing these interests


A modest barrier in a typical PJ housing area.  This one is traversable, but not convenient.  There are plenty of other examples of high fences or mega gates.  No welcoming vibes allowed.


One of my favourites.  Bangsar.



It is not only private property that can cause massive severance - parks, campuses, and other areas in the city are also often fenced, cutting routes for active travel.


Let’s not forget that there are a few success stories, though.   Thumbs up to the golf course near the KL/PJ border that lets you cycle through it (but is it supposed to be a public road anyway..?).


There are good arguments for preventing motorised traffic in certain areas, but do these same arguments hold up against active travel?  That’s where the modal filter steps in. Some housing areas deploy these filters to great effect, blocking cars, and sometimes motorbikes, but remaining open to walking, jogging, or cycling.  There are plenty of examples of this kind of filter around KL, so it’s not something new.  What might be new is integrating it into a transport strategy.


While this discussion has singled out highways and fences as the causes of severance, there are other culprits lurking about in the shadows.  Technology has brought differences in the way the city is planned and constructed.  For example, modern retaining walls can be made much higher more easily than they could a century ago.   Where little terraces would have once been the norm, six metre tall concrete retaining walls now tower around us.  Few of us would consider scaling a wall like that as part of our daily commute, let alone doing it carrying a bicycle. Let’s remember: it is our choice how we implement technology.

 


A final thought - about intuition, and the severing of it.  Intuitively, how to get from A to B?  If you start at A, head in the direction of B mah?  No.  Wrong!  Not in the Klang Valley.  More likely, head in the opposite direction.  This could be different. For a city with a high degree of permeability, if you head towards B, by and large, you will end up at B.  Navigating without a sense of direction is a bizarre concept to me, but something increasingly normal to KLites.  Maybe technology is solving the problem - just got to turn brain off, turn Waze on.  But the tortuous routes we now take add on the miles, add on the minutes, add on the pollution, and add on the stress. 

___

OK, so the city has a problem with permeability, and it’s been heading in the wrong direction for a while.  But there are little positives here and there - modal filters, bicycle maps, footbridges, and private roads open to active travel.  Things that are valued by people.  Let’s build on these things, raise awareness and change minds.  There is a growing group of bicycle users who can spread the word and mobilise.  Who knows, with a few turns of the pedal, we might just get somewhere.

Kampung Attap

People may know Kampung Attap, in central KL, for its cafes, the Zhongshan building, or perhaps the Selangor Badminton association.  It'...